Catch-All Email Verification

Catch-all or accept-all domains can silently derail your outbound campaigns. They accept any address, even fake or inactive ones. That makes them appear valid on the surface, but in reality, most traditional verification tools can’t determine which addresses are real and which are silent spam traps. As a result, legacy email validators mark all catch-all emails as “risky” or “unknown,” leaving your team to guess. 

That’s where Allegrow comes in, a smarter way to detect, classify, and eliminate risky catch-all contacts. We verify individual addresses on catch-all domains using a proprietary signal-based process, so you can reach more valid leads without risking your domain reputation.

‍

What Are Catch-All Emails?

The Hidden Risk in Your Email List

Catch-all email addresses are tied to domains configured to accept messages to any address, whether that address exists or not. On the surface, they seem like a safe bet: they don’t bounce right away, so many basic validators mark them as “valid.”

But in reality, catch-all emails are one of the most deceptive risks in your contact list.

Many catch-all addresses:

• Silently bounce without providing a bounce-back code (also called a Non-Delivery Report or NDR).
• Route emails to admin or misconfigured inboxes, which are often hostile to outbound senders and can trigger company-wide blacklisting
• Be monitored as spam traps by ISPs and blacklists

While some catch-all addresses may trigger hard bounces or auto-responses, these are the minority. Most rejections happen without notice — when misrouted, inactive, or honeypot addresses silently degrade your sender reputation. That’s why verifying them by sending test emails creates false positives and missed threats.

Because they don’t always produce bounces, catch-all addresses often fly under the radar, quietly damaging deliverability and decreasing inbox placement rates across your entire domain.

Why Basic Validation Falls Short

Traditional email validation tools rely on surface-level checks, like using SMTP handshakes to see if the address accepts messages, and confirming whether an email address is correctly formatted (syntax). But these methods can’t tell you if the inbox is active, safe to send to, or silently damaging your deliverability.

Worse, many domains use Secure Email Gateways (SEGs) like Mimecast or Proofpoint that block or reroute mail without returning bounce signals (NDRs). Others suppress bounce responses entirely for unknown or inactive inboxes, especially common in Office 365 and Google Workspace setups. As a result, tools relying on SMTP checks or test sends can’t determine true deliverability.

These tools label catch-all contacts as “risky” or “unknown,” leaving you to guess, and in high-volume outbound, guessing wrong means either flooding sequences with spam traps or cutting 25 to 45% of your list to stay safe.

That’s the dilemma basic validation creates:

• Send to all catch-alls and risk bounce spikes, blacklisting, or spam foldering.
• Avoid them entirely and miss potentially great leads hidden behind valid catch-all inboxes.

While some platforms claim to offer catch-all validation, they stop short of identifying the real, contact-level risk behind the address. (

So how do you stop dangerous catch-alls before they hurt your sender score? With a platform built to verify them at the individual level, not just label them and leave you guessing.

‍

Allegrow’s Approach to Catch-All Email Verification

Stopping catch-all risk isn’t about guesswork — it’s about precision. While most vendors rely on outdated or flawed tactics, Allegrow uses a proprietary method to verify which individual addresses on catch-all domains are real and safe to email. Therefore, we don't just state every contact is 'accept-all' and guess based on email format. We don’t scrape LinkedIn and online sources. And we definitely don’t send fake emails just to see what bounces. 

To understand how Allegrow differs from what you've tried in the past, it's first helpful to clarify the flawed methods some tools and data providers use, so we'll explain the challenges behind each of them first.

Common (and Flawed) Approaches

Domain-Level Catch-All Identification

Many providers claim catch-all verification, but what they actually offer is domain-level identification. They know the domain accepts all mail, but not whether specific addresses are valid. You’re left to guess, or skip them entirely.

Verification by Sending Emails

Some tools attempt to verify catch-all emails by sending fake messages and monitoring for bounces or engagement. But this approach is deeply flawed. Catch-all domains often suppress bounce responses entirely, and any opens or clicks might come from a central inbox the email was rerouted to, like info@company.com. This creates false confidence that the address is valid, when in reality, the actual recipient may not exist at all.

Guessing Based on Online Data

Other tools try to verify catch-all emails by matching standard formats (like first.lastname@domain.com) to names found on LinkedIn or scraped from the web. But this method is highly unreliable. Coverage is limited in many industries, data is often outdated, and just because an address once appeared online doesn’t mean it still exists or can safely receive mail. It’s not verification — it’s educated guessing, and it leads to false positives and deliverability risks at scale.

What Allegrow Does Differently

Allegrow doesn’t guess. Our platform uses a proprietary signal-based system to analyze contact-level indicators and determine whether a catch-all address is safe or risky. It’s not based on syntax patterns or social profile matching, and it’s far more accurate than legacy tools.

While we can’t reveal the inner workings, here’s what you get:

• Individual-level verification of emails on catch-all domains
• Risk scoring based on signals known to correlate with bounce rates, spam complaints, and engagement dead zones
• Automated removal of high-risk contacts from Outreach, Salesloft, and Close CRM

You shouldn’t have to guess on 30% of your list. Allegrow turns catch-all uncertainty into confident decisions and safer, higher-performing outbound.

‍

Why It Matters for B2B Sales Teams

Whether you're sending emails, managing tech, or protecting revenue at scale, catch-all spam traps create hidden risks across the entire sales organization. Allegrow helps each part of your team avoid deliverability threats and stay focused on what actually drives pipeline.

SDR Teams

Catch-all addresses often seem valid, but many never reach a real person. Worse, when a catch-all inbox turns out to be a silent spam trap, your future messages to that domain are more likely to land in spam — even if you're emailing valid contacts later on. Over time, repeated sends to risky catch-all addresses quietly degrade your sender reputation across the board, making it harder to reach real prospects at any domain.

Allegrow prevents this risk by verifying catch-all addresses at the individual level, so your reps focus only on real conversations with real prospects — not undelivered messages that silently harm deliverability.

Outcome: Less wasted outreach, better reply rates.

Sales Operations

For sales ops teams, the challenge isn’t just catching risky contacts — it’s doing it efficiently, across every workflow. Whether contacts enter your sequences via CRM sync, CSV upload, or manual list-building, Allegrow helps by automatically removing high-risk catch-all emails before they can harm sender reputation or derail outbound performance. It simplifies list reviews, reduces manual guesswork, and gives your team more confidence that risky contacts aren’t slipping through.

Outcome: Cleaner cadences, fewer spam triggers, less fire-fighting.

Sales & Revenue Leadership

Catch-all addresses are one of the most common hiding places for spam traps — and once those traps are triggered, the damage lingers. Even if a leadership team member tries to reach a valid prospect later on, emails to that domain often get silently routed to spam, stalling your entire prospecting motion. Worse, if enough traps are hit, your domain reputation suffers across the board.

Allegrow gives peace of mind by verifying catch-all addresses at the individual level, reducing the hidden risks that quietly erode pipeline performance, all while enabling your team to maintain volume targets and drive consistent outbound growth..

Outcome: Scalable sending. Reduced risk. Healthier pipeline.

‍

Results That Speak for Themselves

Proven Impact

Allegrow helps B2B sales teams turn catch-all email risk into a competitive advantage. Because most tools avoid catch-all domains entirely, the valid addresses within them are often underused, making them more likely to respond when reached.

But tapping into that opportunity safely requires precision. Allegrow identifies which catch-all contacts are safe to send and automatically removes hidden threats like spam traps, dead inboxes, and silent bounces.

The result?

• Bounce rates reduced by up to 50%
• Reply rates increased by 200-300% 
• Sender reputation increased to 95%

These aren’t projections, they’re outcomes from real teams managing thousands of outbound emails per week with Allegrow safeguarding their cadences.

Success Stories

Booster – Email Efficiency & Deliverability at Scale

“Our bounce rate dropped by 52% in Q2 this year and dropped by a further 26% in Q3, which is great. [...] When we look overall, too, at just our reply rates, our click rates, our open rates – they've all improved looking at the quarters we've worked with Allegrow this year, compared to last year. For example, our response rate improved by 80%.”

— Lindsay Minnema, Sales Enablement Specialist at Booster

Read the full case study.

Workvivo – 3X Reply Rates with Improved Sender Reputation

“With Outreach campaigns, we’ve seen our reply rates increase by 200–300% using Allegrow to optimize inbox placement. Over the same period of this improvement, we’ve also seen Allegrow has taken our sender reputation score from between 50%–70% to currently 94%.”

— Richard Mullins, Head of Global Business Development at Workvivo

Read the full case study.

Spring Labs – Eliminating Spam Folder Risk

“The biggest issue we had was that employees who were even emailing current clients were still landing in the spam folder. [...] Before, we had a lot of worries about our Head of Product sending a bottom-of-funnel lead some key information and it was going to spam.”

— Alexander Kogan, Director of Finance at Spring Labs

Read the full case study.

‍

Platform Integrations

Works Seamlessly With Your Sales Stack

Catch-all threats shouldn’t be a manual cleanup job. They often go undetected until they start damaging sender reputation or tanking campaign performance. That’s why Allegrow doesn’t just score risky contacts, it actively removes them from your sequences before they can do harm. 

Supported Integrations:

• Outreach
• Salesloft
• Close CRM
• More on their way

For teams with unique workflows or custom tools, Allegrow also offers a dedicated API, making it easy to embed advanced catch-all verification and risk scoring directly into your internal systems or proprietary platforms.

Need help with a custom integration? Talk to our team!